The 199th Pick: How Tom Brady's Historic Draft Position Changed The NFL Forever

Contents
The question of "What pick was Tom Brady?" is more than just a trivia fact; it is the single most important number in modern NFL history, a permanent benchmark for draft evaluation and a testament to the power of intangible qualities over raw athleticism. As of December 23, 2025, the legend of the 199th pick continues to grow, representing the monumental error of judgement by 31 other NFL teams—and the New England Patriots, who passed on him five times—when they overlooked the future greatest quarterback of all time. This deep dive explores the shocking circumstances surrounding the sixth-round selection of Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr., the disastrous scouting reports, and the careers of the six quarterbacks inexplicably chosen ahead of him.

The story of Tom Brady’s draft day is a powerful reminder that the true measure of a player cannot always be captured by a stopwatch or a scouting report. On April 16, 2000, the New England Patriots, led by newly appointed head coach Bill Belichick, used their sixth-round pick to select a skinny, slow, and unheralded quarterback from the University of Michigan, a moment that would redefine an entire era of professional football. The 199th pick was not supposed to be anything special, but it became the foundation for seven Super Bowl championships and a career that spanned over two decades.

Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr. (The G.O.A.T.) Profile & Biography

Before becoming the most decorated player in league history, Tom Brady was a determined college quarterback who consistently had to fight for his starting spot. His journey from an overlooked prospect to the undisputed G.O.A.T. (Greatest Of All Time) is a story of relentless dedication and unmatched competitive fire. Here is a brief look at the biographical profile of the man behind the legendary number 199:

  • Full Name: Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr.
  • Born: August 3, 1977, in San Mateo, California.
  • High School: Junipero Serra High School (San Mateo, CA).
  • College: University of Michigan (Played for the Michigan Wolverines).
  • NFL Draft Year: 2000.
  • NFL Draft Pick: 6th Round, 199th Overall.
  • Drafting Team: New England Patriots.
  • NFL Teams: New England Patriots (2000–2019), Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2020–2022).
  • Career Accomplishments (Select Highlights):
    • 7x Super Bowl Champion (a record for any player or franchise).
    • 5x Super Bowl MVP.
    • 3x NFL Most Valuable Player (MVP).
    • 15x Pro Bowl Selection.
    • NFL All-Time Leader in Passing Yards, Passing Touchdowns, and Wins.

The Shocking Reason Why Tom Brady Was Picked 199th Overall

The primary reason Tom Brady fell to the sixth round of the 2000 NFL Draft was a devastating combination of unimpressive physical tools and a lack of dominant college production. In the late 90s and early 2000s, NFL scouts prioritized quarterbacks with elite arm strength and athletic mobility, two areas where the Michigan signal-caller was severely lacking. His performance at the NFL Scouting Combine in Indianapolis painted a particularly bleak picture for his draft stock.

The Disastrous 2000 NFL Combine Performance

The lasting image of Brady's pre-draft process is the infamous shirtless photo from the Combine, which showed a lanky, non-muscular build that did not scream "NFL quarterback." His measurable results were equally underwhelming.

  • 40-Yard Dash: He clocked a painfully slow 5.28 seconds, making him the second-slowest quarterback at the Combine that year.
  • Vertical Jump: A modest 24.5 inches.
  • Scouting Report Quotes: The official scouting reports were brutal. One circulated report noted a "Poor Build," describing him as "Skinny" and lacking "great physical stature and strength." Other criticisms included, "Lacks mobility and the ability to avoid the rush," and crucially, "Lacks a strong arm" and "Cannot drive the ball."

In an era that was beginning to favor more mobile quarterbacks, Brady was seen as a pocket statue with average-at-best velocity. Scouts were looking for the next John Elway or Brett Favre, not a player whose best asset, as he himself stated, was his "mental toughness." The consensus was that he was a smart, tough, but ultimately physically limited player who would struggle to adapt to the speed of the professional game.

The Six Quarterbacks Drafted Before The 199th Pick

The most compelling part of the 199th pick's legacy is the list of quarterbacks who were chosen before him. A total of six signal-callers were selected by teams in the first five rounds, all of whom are now footnotes in NFL history compared to the man they preceded. Their collective career statistics pale in comparison to Brady’s individual records, highlighting one of the greatest misses in draft history.

Here are the six quarterbacks drafted ahead of Tom Brady in the 2000 NFL Draft, showcasing the monumental error in judgment by NFL general managers and scouting departments:

  1. Chad Pennington: Selected 18th overall (1st Round) by the New York Jets. Pennington had a respectable, albeit injury-plagued, career and was the most successful of the six.
  2. Giovanni Carmazzi: Selected 65th overall (3rd Round) by the San Francisco 49ers. Carmazzi never played a single down in the NFL regular season.
  3. Chris Redman: Selected 75th overall (3rd Round) by the Baltimore Ravens. Redman served primarily as a backup throughout his career.
  4. Tee Martin: Selected 163rd overall (5th Round) by the Pittsburgh Steelers. Martin also failed to establish himself, playing only a handful of games.
  5. Marc Bulger: Selected 168th overall (6th Round) by the St. Louis Rams. Bulger was the second most successful, making two Pro Bowls with the Rams.
  6. Spergon Wynn: Selected 183rd overall (6th Round) by the Cleveland Browns. Wynn’s NFL career was short-lived, playing for only two seasons.

In a stunning statistic that underlines the gap, the six quarterbacks drafted before Brady combined for 238 career starts, while Brady himself made 365 regular season starts alone. The collective legacy of these six players is now inextricably linked to the man whose name was called 199th.

The Legacy of the 199th Pick: A Cautionary Tale for Scouts

The 199th pick is now a symbol of hope for every late-round draft prospect and a permanent cautionary tale for NFL scouting departments. The New England Patriots, under the guidance of Bill Belichick and personnel executive Scott Pioli, saw something in Brady that others missed: the intangibles. They valued his intelligence, his leadership, his work ethic, and his quick release—qualities that don't show up on a 40-yard dash clock.

The Patriots themselves passed on Brady five times before finally selecting him with their compensatory pick in the sixth round. This is a common occurrence in the draft, but the fact that they kept four quarterbacks on the roster in 2000, specifically because they liked Brady so much, shows that they had a higher conviction in him than his draft slot suggests. He spent his first season as the fourth-string quarterback behind starter Drew Bledsoe, diligently working on his physique and football knowledge.

The trajectory of his career, from a sixth-round project to the most clutch quarterback in Super Bowl history—winning championships with both the Patriots and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers—has fundamentally shifted how teams evaluate the quarterback position. Today, more emphasis is placed on "football IQ," "pocket presence," and "leadership skills," all traits that Brady possessed in abundance. The 199th pick is no longer just a number; it is a monument to the power of self-belief and a constant reminder that in the NFL Draft, sometimes the biggest treasures are found in the deepest rounds.

what pick was tom brady
what pick was tom brady

Detail Author:

  • Name : Ms. Vivian Donnelly
  • Username : aliya17
  • Email : aiyana79@brown.org
  • Birthdate : 1975-09-16
  • Address : 729 Wehner Road Suite 545 West Shannyhaven, OR 53367-7941
  • Phone : +1-830-859-6304
  • Company : Hills-Wilkinson
  • Job : Occupational Therapist Assistant
  • Bio : Qui ea error molestias nemo. Vel similique et sint aut. Illo veniam et enim velit sed ut quos earum.

Socials

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/koss2011
  • username : koss2011
  • bio : Delectus quaerat eum quod dolore reiciendis iusto. Et placeat odit minus libero. Velit provident sed deserunt voluptas.
  • followers : 125
  • following : 728

linkedin:

facebook:

  • url : https://facebook.com/deron_id
  • username : deron_id
  • bio : Blanditiis dignissimos nisi rerum consectetur omnis dolore qui.
  • followers : 3650
  • following : 663