Home Ziharkah

The Ultimate Breakdown: Did Jeremiah Fisher Really Cheat On Belly Conklin? (Book Vs. Show)

• minute read
Contents

The question of whether Jeremiah Fisher betrayed Belly Conklin is the most hotly debated topic in The Summer I Turned Pretty universe, and the answer is not a simple yes or no. As of the current date in December 2025, with Season 3 of the hit Prime Video series now airing, the pivotal moment of betrayal has been adapted from the book, confirming a major relationship shake-up that will ultimately determine Belly’s final choice between the Fisher brothers.

The controversy stems from a key event in the third book of the trilogy, *We'll Always Have Summer*, which has now been brought to the screen. While the word "cheating" is often used by fans, the author herself has offered a more nuanced interpretation, suggesting the situation is "debatable." This deep dive will break down the exact plot points in the books and the show, the context of the betrayal, and the lasting consequences for the beloved characters at Cousins Beach.

The Complete Biography of the Fisher Brothers and Belly Conklin

To understand the high-stakes drama of the love triangle, it's essential to know the key players involved in this complex and often heartbreaking story, which spans years of summers and deep emotional connections.

  • Isabel "Belly" Conklin: The protagonist and narrator of the story. She is inextricably linked to the Fisher family through her mother, Laurel, and her deep, lifelong connection to Cousins Beach. Her journey focuses on navigating first love, loss, and choosing between two brothers.
  • Jeremiah "Jere" Fisher: The younger of the two Fisher brothers. He is characterized by his golden-boy charm, easygoing personality, and emotional openness. He is Belly’s first true boyfriend and, eventually, her fiancé in the book series. He studies at Brown University in the later part of the story.
  • Conrad "Con" Fisher: The older Fisher brother. He is often moody, reserved, and brooding, but possesses a deep intellectual and emotional intensity. He is Belly's first crush and her eventual endgame in the books. He also attends Brown University, though their paths diverge.
  • Steven Conklin: Belly's older brother and Conrad's close friend. He often serves as a sounding board and protective figure for Belly, though he remains mostly outside the central love triangle.
  • Laurel Park: Belly and Steven's mother, a successful author and Susannah's best friend.
  • Susannah Fisher: Jeremiah and Conrad's mother, who is Belly's beloved surrogate aunt. Her illness and death are central to the trilogy's emotional core.

The Definitive Answer: Did Jeremiah Cheat on Belly in the Books?

The short answer is yes, but with a massive caveat that centers on a technicality that has fueled "Team Jeremiah" vs. "Team Conrad" wars for years.

The "We Were On a Break" Moment in *We'll Always Have Summer*

The pivotal event occurs in the third book of the trilogy, *We'll Always Have Summer*. Belly and Jeremiah are a committed couple, attending college together. Their relationship hits a major rough patch, primarily due to the stresses of college life, their individual insecurities, and the looming shadow of Conrad.

During a period of intense fighting and distance, Jeremiah attends a party. The next day, he confesses to Belly that he kissed another girl at the party. This girl is later revealed to be Lacie Barone, a key entity in the betrayal storyline.

The crucial, "Ross from Friends" moment is the context of the kiss. Jeremiah claims that he and Belly were "on a break" when the kiss happened, a defense that Belly vehemently rejects, feeling deeply betrayed and heartbroken. While some readers and the author, Jenny Han, have noted that it's "debatable" whether this technically constitutes "cheating" in a strict sense, the emotional damage and the breach of trust are undeniable. For Belly, the betrayal is real, and it shatters the foundation of their relationship, leading to their eventual engagement and subsequent breakup.

The Shocking Adaptation: Jeremiah's Betrayal in *The Summer I Turned Pretty* Season 3

Fans of the Amazon Prime Video series have been anxiously awaiting this moment, knowing it is the catalyst for Belly’s final decision. Based on recent information and episode spoilers for Season 3, the show has fully embraced this controversial plot point.

The Lacie Barone Reveal

The series adaptation, which is expected to cover the events of the third book, includes the betrayal storyline. The Season 3 premiere, or a very early episode, reportedly features the dramatic reveal, possibly through Belly overhearing a conversation about Jeremiah and Lacie Barone at a party. This is a crucial element of the show's narrative, as it is the major turning point that pushes Belly away from Jeremiah and back toward Conrad.

The show's structure and the use of the "Lacie Barone" entity confirm that the creative team, led by author Jenny Han, felt this moment of betrayal—regardless of the "on a break" technicality—was essential to the story. It serves to highlight the difference in emotional maturity and communication between the two brothers and Belly. While Jeremiah's actions are a clear breach of trust, the show also explores the pressure and codependency that marked their college relationship.

The Double Standard: Did Belly Cheat on Jeremiah First?

To further complicate the narrative, some fans and critics point out that Belly herself was not entirely innocent in the relationship. In Season 1 and the first book, Belly is dating Jeremiah when she shares a significant kiss with Conrad. This is often cited as an emotional and physical betrayal, which adds a layer of complexity to the "cheating" debate:

  • Belly's Betrayal: Her lingering feelings for Conrad and the kiss, while she was officially with Jeremiah, show that the emotional lines in the love triangle were always blurred.
  • Jeremiah's Betrayal: His kiss with Lacie Barone, even if during a "break," was a physical act that broke Belly's trust and led to a dramatic confrontation.

The show and books present a situation where both halves of the "Jelly" relationship struggle with fidelity and communication, making the story feel more realistic and messy. The core issue is not simply who cheated, but the impact of these betrayals on their shared history and future.

The Long-Term Consequences for the Fisher Brothers

Jeremiah's actions, whether labeled as "cheating" or "betrayal during a break," have massive ramifications that drive the final act of the story. The incident is not just a moment of drama; it is the catalyst for the end of the "Jelly" relationship and the eventual resolution of the love triangle.

The Engagement and the Aftermath

In the book, the betrayal leads to a desperate attempt by Belly and Jeremiah to salvage their relationship: they get engaged. This rushed decision is a clear example of their desire to cling to the safety and familiarity of their bond, rather than confront the difficult emotions and lack of trust. Their engagement is short-lived, and the underlying issues, exacerbated by the betrayal, ultimately lead them to break up.

The Path to Conrad

The breakup with Jeremiah clears the path for Belly to finally explore a mature relationship with Conrad Fisher. The betrayal serves as a painful but necessary realization for Belly that her relationship with Jeremiah, while fun and comfortable, was not the deep, enduring love she needed. The dramatic events of Season 3, including the Lacie Barone reveal, are setting the stage for the highly anticipated "Team Conrad" ending that book readers know is coming.

In conclusion, while the technical definition of "cheating" remains a point of contention among fans and the author, Jeremiah Fisher did commit a significant act of betrayal by kissing Lacie Barone while he and Belly were on a break. This moment is a key, undeniable plot point in the final book and is now a central, dramatic element of The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, forever changing the dynamic between Belly and the Fisher brothers.

The Ultimate Breakdown: Did Jeremiah Fisher Really Cheat on Belly Conklin? (Book vs. Show)
does jeremiah cheat on belly
does jeremiah cheat on belly

Detail Author:

  • Name : Dr. Johanna Bode
  • Username : mathew.prosacco
  • Email : orrin.buckridge@gmail.com
  • Birthdate : 1973-12-27
  • Address : 94293 Donnelly Neck New Floyport, MO 32395-6700
  • Phone : 1-804-507-2256
  • Company : Gulgowski Ltd
  • Job : Stock Broker
  • Bio : Iure esse quia libero facere omnis dolorem. Omnis libero dolor veritatis accusantium aut pariatur sed. Soluta maiores sed neque voluptas sit sed. Iure nam rerum quia quas veritatis voluptatem.

Socials

facebook:

instagram:

linkedin:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/beer2010
  • username : beer2010
  • bio : Cumque officia labore asperiores. Eum illum repellendus ipsum atque officiis quidem amet atque. Id sed consequatur cupiditate at.
  • followers : 131
  • following : 166

Random Posts